Walk-In Shower vs. Tub Combo: Which is Right for Your Bathroom?

The shower-or-tub debate is one of the first decisions Rockwall homeowners make in a bathroom remodel. Here's how to choose based on your lifestyle, North Texas resale value trends, and bathroom size to maximize your investment.

Walk-In Showers: Pros and Cons

Advantages:

• Accessibility: No step-over barrier makes them ideal for aging in place, mobility concerns, or universal design

• Modern Aesthetic: Clean lines, glass enclosures, and spa-like features create luxury hotel vibes

• Space Efficiency: Frameless glass makes small bathrooms feel larger; curbless showers can visually expand the floor

• Low Maintenance: No grout lines around a tub rim, easier to clean large-format tile

• Customization: Built-in benches, multiple shower heads, rainfall fixtures, steam features

Drawbacks:

• Not ideal for bathing young children or pets

• May impact resale value if it's your home's only bathroom

• Requires proper waterproofing and drainage (especially for curbless designs)

Tub/Shower Combos: Pros and Cons

Advantages:

• Versatility: Both bathing and showering options in one footprint

• Family-Friendly: Essential for homes with young children

• Resale Value: Most buyers expect at least one tub in the home

• Space Savings: Standard 60" alcove tubs fit in compact spaces

• Cost-Effective: Generally less expensive than custom walk-in showers

Drawbacks:

• Step-over height can be a barrier as you age

• Tub/shower surrounds show water spots and soap scum more readily

• Shower curtains feel dated; glass doors on tubs can be cramped

• Less design flexibility than walk-in showers

How to Decide: Key Questions

1. How many bathrooms do you have?

If you have multiple bathrooms, dedicate at least one to a tub (usually the main/hall bath) and go all-in on a luxury shower in the primary suite. Single-bathroom homes should keep a tub for resale appeal and practicality.

2. Do you have young children or pets?

Tubs are non-negotiable for bathing toddlers and washing dogs. Even if you prefer showers now, think 5-10 years ahead.

3. How long do you plan to stay in the home?

Long-term homeowners can prioritize personal preferences (walk-in showers for aging in place). Short-term owners should consider broad buyer appeal (keep at least one tub).

4. What's your bathroom's square footage?

Under 50 sq ft: Tub/shower combo is most efficient. 50-75 sq ft: Either works; consider your lifestyle. Over 75 sq ft: Walk-in shower with separate soaking tub is ideal if budget allows.

The Best-of-Both-Worlds Option

If space and budget permit, install a freestanding soaking tub separate from a large walk-in shower. This gives you:

✓ The luxury and accessibility of a walk-in shower

✓ A statement tub for relaxation (and resale appeal)

✓ Flexibility for future needs

✓ Maximum design impact

This layout works beautifully in primary bathrooms 80+ square feet and is our most-requested configuration for high-end remodels.

What We Recommend

For Primary Bathrooms: Walk-in shower with rainfall head, handheld wand, built-in bench, and niche storage. If space allows, add a freestanding tub.

For Hall/Kids' Bathrooms: Tub/shower combo with upgraded tile surround (skip the fiberglass insert) and quality glass door.

For Guest Bathrooms: Walk-in shower works great since guests rarely need tubs, and it creates a hotel-like experience.

Cost Comparison

Tub/Shower Combo: $4,000-8,000 including tile surround, quality fixtures, glass door

Walk-In Shower: $7,000-15,000 for custom tile work, frameless glass, premium fixtures

Separate Shower + Tub: $15,000-30,000+ depending on tub choice (alcove vs. freestanding) and shower features

Shower vs. Tub FAQs

Will removing the only tub in my home hurt resale value?

Yes. If your home has a single bathroom, keep a tub/shower combo. Buyers expect at least one tub for bathing kids or pets, so we recommend reserving tub removals for homes with multiple baths.

Are walk-in showers easier to maintain?

They typically are. Large-format tile, frameless glass, and fewer corners mean less scrubbing and no tub ledge to collect soap scum—just be sure waterproofing is handled by pros.

What is the best option for families with small children?

A tub/shower combo in the hall or kids’ bath is the most flexible solution. You can still build a luxury walk-in shower in the primary suite for everyday use.

How much space do I need for a separate tub and shower?

Plan for at least 75-80 square feet. That footprint allows a generous walk-in shower plus a freestanding or alcove tub without crowding the room.